Most US practice sales are asset sales. Buyers prefer them because they can deduct what they pay for goodwill over 15 years and leave old liabilities behind.1 Sellers usually prefer a stock sale because more of the gain is a capital gain. In an asset sale, your tax depends on how the price is split among equipment, receivables, goodwill, a non-compete and your future pay, and both sides report that split to the IRS.2 The QSBS exclusion doesn't help: businesses performing services in the field of health are excluded.3
Why buyers want to buy assets
When a buyer purchases assets, it gets a new tax cost for what it bought. It can depreciate the equipment again and deduct goodwill, non-competes and most other intangibles evenly over 15 years.1 It also leaves the old company's liabilities behind: past billing errors, old contracts, tax years still open to audit.
In states with corporate practice of medicine rules, a non-physician buyer often can't own the shares of a professional corporation anyway, so it buys the non-clinical assets through a management company. See MSOs and the corporate practice of medicine.
Why sellers want to sell stock
In a stock sale, your whole gain is usually a capital gain, and the liabilities go with the company. You walk away cleaner. That is why the two sides start from opposite positions, and why the structure gets negotiated alongside the price.
How an asset sale gets taxed, piece by piece
The price is allocated across classes of assets using the method in section 1060, and both buyer and seller report the split on Form 8594.42 For a seller using a pass-through entity, the pieces are usually taxed like this:
| Piece of the price | How it is usually taxed for you |
|---|---|
| Equipment and furniture | Ordinary income up to the depreciation you already took; any gain above that is generally capital |
| Receivables, in a cash-basis practice | Ordinary income, because they were never taxed |
| Supplies | Ordinary income |
| Goodwill | Usually long-term capital gain |
| Payment for your non-compete | Ordinary income |
| Pay for working after the sale | Ordinary income, as wages |
The buyer wants more of the price in pieces it can deduct quickly. You want more in goodwill. Both of you have to stay within what an independent valuation could support.
The C corporation trap, and personal goodwill
If your practice is a C corporation, an asset sale is taxed twice: the corporation pays tax on the gain, and you pay tax again when the proceeds come out as a dividend or in liquidation.
The main way around it is personal goodwill. Tax Court cases from 1998, Martin Ice Cream and Norwalk, accepted that a shareholder-employee's personal relationships are not corporate assets when no employment contract or non-compete ties them to the corporation. Goodwill that belongs to you can be sold by you directly and taxed once.5
The cases also show how it fails. In Howard v. United States, decided by the Ninth Circuit in 2011, a dentist had signed an employment agreement with a non-compete in favor of his own corporation years earlier. The court held the goodwill belonged to the corporation, so the payment allocated to his personal goodwill was taxed as a corporate sale followed by a dividend.65
If you run a C corporation and a sale is a few years away:
- Read every agreement you have with your own corporation, especially employment agreements and non-competes.
- Get an independent valuation that separates personal from enterprise goodwill.
- Keep the allocation to personal goodwill reasonable. Overreaching invites a challenge.
Why QSBS doesn't help physicians
The qualified small business stock exclusion in section 1202 can make gain on certain C corporation shares tax-free. It doesn't apply to businesses performing services in the field of health, which covers physician practices.3
Other taxes to model
- Net investment income tax. A 3.8% tax that can apply to some gains, depending on whether the income counts as investment income for you.7
- State tax. Rates and rules vary widely, and where you live when you sell can matter.
- Installment sales. If part of the price comes as a note paid over time, you may be able to report the gain as payments arrive.8
- Rollover equity. The part of your price reinvested in the buyer can often be structured to defer tax, if it is set up correctly from the start.
If you practice in Canada
The same tension exists, with different tools. A share sale may let you use the lifetime capital gains exemption, worth up to C$1,275,000 of gain in 2026, while an asset sale is taxed inside your corporation first. The Canada guide walks through it.
The order of operations
- Agree with the buyer whether the deal is an asset or stock sale, as early as the LOI.
- Have your accountant model after-tax proceeds for each structure and allocation.
- Get an independent valuation, including personal goodwill if it applies.
- Write the allocation into the purchase agreement.
- File consistent Forms 8594 for the tax year of the sale.
Questions owners ask
Is goodwill taxed as a capital gain?
Usually, if you sell through a pass-through entity such as an S corporation or an LLC taxed as a partnership. In a C corporation, the corporation pays tax on the gain and you pay again when the money comes out, unless the goodwill is personal to you and sold by you directly.
Who decides how the price is allocated?
You and the buyer negotiate it, within the rules of section 1060, and both of you report it on Form 8594.42 Agree it in the purchase agreement so both returns match.
Will a buyer pay more for an asset deal?
Sometimes. The buyer's tax deductions on goodwill have real value, so you can ask for part of it back in the price, especially if an asset sale costs you more tax than a stock sale would.
Can I use the QSBS exclusion when I sell?
Not for a medical practice. Section 1202 excludes businesses that perform services in the field of health.3
Is an earnout taxed like the rest of the price?
Usually, if it is tied to the business's results. If it depends on you staying employed, it can be treated as pay and taxed as ordinary income instead. Your lawyer and accountant should look at the wording together.
Sources
- U.S. Code, via Cornell LII, 26 U.S.C. 197, amortization of goodwill and certain other intangibles, current.
- Internal Revenue Service, About Form 8594, Asset Acquisition Statement Under Section 1060, current.
- U.S. Code, via Cornell LII, 26 U.S.C. 1202, partial exclusion for gain from certain small business stock, current.
- U.S. Code, via Cornell LII, 26 U.S.C. 1060, special allocation rules for certain asset acquisitions, current.
- Journal of Accountancy, Personal goodwill: Who owns it?, November 2010.
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Howard v. United States, No. 10-35768 (memorandum), August 2011.
- Internal Revenue Service, Net Investment Income Tax, current.
- U.S. Code, via Cornell LII, 26 U.S.C. 453, installment method, current.
This guide is general information for clinic owners in the United States and Canada, current as of November 17, 2026. It is not legal, tax or financial advice. Laws differ by state and province, so take any offer to your own lawyer and accountant before you sign.